Sep 28, · You May Also Find These Documents Helpful against affirmative action Essay. Is it the responsible of Universities, especially public ones to change their Arguments Against Affirmative Action Essay. This quote by David Duke (politician) sums up Louis P. Pojman argues in his article, The Case against Affirmative Action, that even in extreme cases reverse racism and strong affirmative action are wrong. Pojman differentiates between strong and weak affirmative action and in his article he focus on strong affirmative action Jan 26, · The first argument against affirmative action is that people should be chosen based on merit and not by race or gender. Just as it is discriminatory to deny minorities and women positions because they are not white Affirmative action does not solve the issues at the root of racial and gender inequality
Argument Against Affirmative Action Example | Graduateway
We use cookies to give you the best experience possible. The Constitution of the United States of America states that all people are created equal, and that is how all Americans should be treated. Against affirmative action essay action has long since served a good purpose in American society. It appears to take advantage of hard-working Americans who are not protected under its umbrella. Don't use plagiarized sources. It is impossible to give reparations to certain groups solely based on their race for injustices set upon their ancestors in the past without offending the majority of other races.
Also, affirmative action was designed to decrease racism in schools and jobs by providing otherwise unavailable access to social networks. Now that this access has been established, it is time for affirmative action to end. Galston There appears to be several large holes in this action.
internment of Asians during WWII, and allowing slavery in the sit cannot merely give these to any member of that race. For example, millions of immigrants migrated to this country after these events occurred. This suggests that the government is giving special treatment to immigrants who were never mistreated by our government.
The government should not be giving these special privileges to any person that just steps foot into this country. This is where members against affirmative action essay races who are not protected under affirmative action get taken advantage of.
Grapes 47 Affirmative action is a nice way in which to say discrimination. It fits the definition exactly in that it gives preference to some individuals and therefore the disfavoring of others.
Two wrongs do not make a right. On one hand the government stresses that racism is bad but, at the same time, condones it by allowing affirmative action to take place in this great nation, against affirmative action essay. This poses a great problem in society.
People not covered under affirmative action against affirmative action essay have made it through an institution of higher education are coming out of college and having trouble finding work suited for their level of knowledge. This is partly due to the fact that businesses have to hire a percentage of minorities, and there are simply just not enough spots open for these unprotected college students.
Now these students, who are trying to pay off student loans, are having to settle for against affirmative action essay paying jobs for which they are over qualified.
Keys Affirmative action promotes racism. It promotes racism from non-minorities when minorities are given opportunities based solely on their race. This is another example of how affirmative action does the opposite of what it is supposed to do. Grapes 48 Under Affirmative Action, colleges and other places of higher education are given a quota of how many minority students must attend their institutions.
This is not fair to the colleges as it may place some unreasonable restrictions on recruitment during the admissions process. College admissions representatives must now, in addition to the other qualifying standards, factor in the race of the students applying instead of looking at their academics, personal achievements, and quality of work the student will afford the institution.
Additionally, this creates reverse prejudices against the people who are not covered under the umbrella of affirmative action. These quotas are allowing people into schools based predominantly on their race. Oftentimes the minority students that are accepted against affirmative action essay less qualified than the people who are not covered under affirmative action, against affirmative action essay.
Messereli The national average of blacks who graduate from college with a degree is very low. Only forty percent of them actually graduate. This means that less than half of all black college students will graduate with a degree. The graduation rate for non-minorities is sixty-one percent. This poses a problem. Furthermore, it discriminates against non-minority students. This is taking away the spots of non-minority students who sixty-one percent of the time graduate.
This makes very little sense at all. Edwards Affirmative Action can also hurt minorities, however. Many times, since schools need to accept a certain number of minorities, colleges admit students who have lower GPAs and SAT scores than the norm of that school. This often puts the minorities at a disadvantage because they are expected to maintain the high standards of the college, which leads to an increase in the failure rate, against affirmative action essay. It would be like putting a minor league player into the pros and expect him to excel at batting clean-up.
Grapes In many Ivy league schools against affirmative action essay average GPA for non-minority students they were accepting was a 4. The average for the minority students they were accepting was below a 3. Standards are supposed to be set to push students to do better. Further, it lowers the level of accountability for these students. This is another example of how affirmative action hurts the hard-working man or woman.
Grapes 73 At the University of Colorado, the test scores between black students and white students were very different. The test score differences between black and white students were more than points. This translated into only 39 percent of the black students graduating whereas the number of white students graduating was 72 percent. At the University of Against affirmative action essay at Denver, the SAT score only varied by against affirmative action essay 30 points between white students and black students.
The graduation rate of black students translated into 50 percent and the white students against affirmative action essay percent. Sowell The United States of America does not need affirmative action. This has been proven in against affirmative action essay two states in which it was banned in colleges. When affirmative action was outlawed in California and Texas, there was excessive bashing in the media. They thought that it would keep minorities out of college when, in fact, the opposite happened.
There are now more minorities enrolled in college than there were during the days of affirmative action, against affirmative action essay.
Sowell Also, it is condescending to minorities. This makes it against affirmative action essay difficult for minorities to ever validate their achievements. If someone were to ask Colin Powell if the reason he got to where he is today was because of affirmative action, he would likely be very offended. Just as quotas are set for colleges, against affirmative action essay, quotas are set for employers.
Many times employers have to settle for less qualified workers so that they can meet the quotas set by the government. For example, say a fireman is teamed with a less qualified minority partner because the fire department has to hire a specific amount of minorities. Not only is this unfair, but it is extremely dangerous, both to the fireman and any victims that he or she needs to rescue.
Also, in society, non-minorities who against affirmative action essay hold positions lose their jobs to minorities so that the employer can meet his quota. This argument makes no sense at all. There would be little to no argument if the government had decided to give reparations to those people who had actually suffered those injuries, against affirmative action essay.
Grapes 48 Unfortunately, as stated above, affirmative action promotes reverse discrimination. Basically reverse discrimination is the condition under which there is preferential treatment of one group minorities and women over another group, against affirmative action essay, rather than equal opportunity. Giving the job positions to less qualified candidates is favoritism; this harms those who should be obtaining the job position.
A dedicated person who worked hard his or her whole life could lose a position to a minority that slipped into the position undeservingly. The whole purpose of affirmative action was to eliminate favoritism; instead it shifts favoritism to the other side. Favoritism of this sort does nothing but imply that minorities need special treatment to succeed in life. Highly merited minorities past professors have told me personally that minorities do not need special treatment; they need equal treatment.
They past professors told me that affirmative action implies that all minorities are inferior to whites and that minorities need to be treated with special care just to have a chance to become successful. The affirmative action program also undermines their past professors achievements of minorities by implying that their positions were handed to them rather than being earned, against affirmative action essay.
Affirmative action in collegiate admissions has proven to be one of the most controversial issues of the era. In this area both against affirmative action essay and non-minorities are discriminated against, when affirmative action was in use the admissions board was divided into two groups one for minorities and another for non-minorities, standards for both groups were different.
Once again affirmative action is showing favoritism. A recent example of affirmative action in collegiate admissions includes Gratz and Hamacher vs, against affirmative action essay.
University of Michigan. Gratz and Hamacher alleged that unlawful preference to minorities in University of Michigan undergraduate admissions. This also reminds me of when I was a senior in high school, against affirmative action essay, several black colleges wanted me to come to there school to play football on a scholarship. What they did not tell me was that I would receive a minority scholarship not a football scholarship, against affirmative action essay.
Basically they found a loophole; they could recruit white players and give them minority scholarships and still have the same number of football scholarships to give out. They were getting a two for one deal by improving their number of minority white students students and getting football players at the same time. Affirmative action has a huge negative impact on our economy; it is costly and could destroy the legitimacy of minorities. In the business world, the main concern of an employer should be to hire the most qualified person that will increase productivity.
The concern should not be to hire a racially diverse against affirmative action essay. How can the most qualified person for the job be hired if the hiring is done on race rather than merit? It makes no sense. Hiring on something rather than merit may result in economic hardship and a less qualified staff. If minorities have a qualified resume and are available, they will meet the criteria of the employer and will be hired on merit and not on diversifying the company.
Giving unqualified minorities employment simply treats the symptoms. Affirmative action also promotes racial preference. Racial preferences are founded on the proposition that the achievements of their beneficiaries would be fewer if the preferences did not exist.
Racial preferences should be insulting to all minorities; no minority is inferior to any white and neither is a female to any male. Only by eliminating race-based preferences can America reach the ideas set forth against affirmative action essay Martin Luther King Jr.
Asian Americans and Higher Education: An End to Affirmative Action?
, time: 1:27:22Argumentative Essay On Affirmative Action
Louis P. Pojman argues in his article, The Case against Affirmative Action, that even in extreme cases reverse racism and strong affirmative action are wrong. Pojman differentiates between strong and weak affirmative action and in his article he focus on strong affirmative action Jan 26, · The first argument against affirmative action is that people should be chosen based on merit and not by race or gender. Just as it is discriminatory to deny minorities and women positions because they are not white Affirmative action does not solve the issues at the root of racial and gender inequality The reason it is wrong is because it's discrimination. It has no place in today's society in today's society because it does more bad than good. In addition to that most people don't enjoy the presence of affirmative action. Also, it appears that affirmativ Estimated Reading Time: 6 mins
No comments:
Post a Comment